Savvy’s are great looking and very open. I would only do aluminum too which all options you listed have. My concern with the savvy is the inner fender isn’t easy to mount stuff on.
Genrights are the gold standard
Motobilts are similar to the old poison spyder aluminum fenders that were discontinued for a design problem making them crack. So far I havnt heard of this issue in the Motobilts but it was my concern with them especially since they’re now the same or more money than genrights.
@Fluxor or
fluxoffroad.com is now designing some which I am super interested in as he is trying to make a flared version but the flare is removable for off-roading. They’re in the design phase still so not sure how soon you’re looking to get them.