We have the dual ARB in the JL. While it's nowhere close to the YORK in the TJ it gets the job done. I'd say about 2-3 min a tire from 15-30psi while the York is a minute from 8-25psi. I think the only real advantage of a tank, other than if you need pressure for lockers, would be you'll have a bit more pressure built if you run air tools.
You should casually mention that to our Utah friend. He's very happy with his.
He is not airing up 37 and 40" tires. I likely wouldn't be bothered for 35's.
