Engine swap comparison

The syncros on my NV3550 just died and got replaced with an AX-15 like less than 10,000 miles ago

Look on car-part.com for the Dakota bellhousing and make sure you ask for the dust cover too.

Used to be able to buy them for $75... WOW $300 now

1755043045201.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: KingCarGuyZ
Current "reman" (I hesitate to call it a rebuild) parts list:

- Silv-o-lite 3241HC.STD pistons
- Hastings 2M4815 rings
- Fel-pro gasket kit (FEL-260-2000)
- Flex-Hone
- Ring compressor
- Head studs (Thanks @macleanflood)

Debating a Melling M167HVS "standard volume" pump and pickup.

and a prayer, Intentionally chose not to replace bearings or lifters, as I am not replacing rods or cam shafts so it seems like the internets opinion is to let sleeping dogs lie.

All of this totals out to about $520, so any stock for stock swap would have to come In under $500 to be cost affective, and would likely be more labor intensive.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Wildman
Timing chain and rear main are probably going to stay as im trying to do this in the Jeep

Head studs is a good call.

Rear main is a two piece seal and accessed under the rear main bearing cap...which, coincidentally you're already removing.

Timing chain...and I'd add a crank pulley are just under a front cover below the water pump. As most you'd need to remove the radiator. If nothing else you can wiggle the chain with the oil pan off and decide if you want to go for it.

With your milage I'd really recommend it.

-Mac
 
$500 later parts are OTW, hopefully I can get this all refreshed in a weekend. Rock Auto wound up having cheaper prices on everything but the Pistons if anyone decides to follow in my footsteps.
Current "reman" (I hesitate to call it a rebuild) parts list:

- Silv-o-lite 3241HC.STD pistons
- Hastings 2M4815 rings
- Fel-pro gasket kit (FEL-260-2000)
- Flex-Hone
- Ring compressor
- Head studs (Thanks @macleanflood)

Debating a Melling M167HVS "standard volume" pump and pickup.

and a prayer, Intentionally chose not to replace bearings or lifters, as I am not replacing rods or cam shafts so it seems like the internets opinion is to let sleeping dogs lie.

All of this totals out to about $520, so any stock for stock swap would have to come In under $500 to be cost affective, and would likely be more labor intensive.
 
Current "reman" (I hesitate to call it a rebuild) parts list:

- Silv-o-lite 3241HC.STD pistons
- Hastings 2M4815 rings
- Fel-pro gasket kit (FEL-260-2000)
- Flex-Hone
- Ring compressor
- Head studs (Thanks @macleanflood)

Debating a Melling M167HVS "standard volume" pump and pickup.

and a prayer, Intentionally chose not to replace bearings or lifters, as I am not replacing rods or cam shafts so it seems like the internets opinion is to let sleeping dogs lie.

All of this totals out to about $520, so any stock for stock swap would have to come In under $500 to be cost affective, and would likely be more labor intensive.

I run the high volume Melling equivalent and have had good success with it. (Note that part number is the high volume.)

One of their sales reps gave me the info on displacement. The high volume is 0.067 gallons per revolution. High flow is 20% higher than standard volume for reference, so standard volume is 0.056 gallons per revolution.

Note that oil pump RPM is half that of engine RPM.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wildman
Rear main is a two piece seal and accessed under the rear main bearing cap...which, coincidentally you're already removing.

Timing chain...and I'd add a crank pulley are just under a front cover below the water pump. As most you'd need to remove the radiator. If nothing else you can wiggle the chain with the oil pan off and decide if you want to go for it.

With your milage I'd really recommend it.

-Mac

+1

I did the timing chain, front crank seal, and the harmonic balancer pulley on mine this winter, and had plenty of room with the radiator still in the Jeep (4.0L).
 
+1

I did the timing chain, front crank seal, and the harmonic balancer pulley on mine this winter, and had plenty of room with the radiator still in the Jeep (4.0L).

yeah, from a time perspective that going to wind up pushed to the next time I'm down there have to keep this all under 48 hours down time.
 
This popped up in my YouTube feed last night. Seemed relevant to the discussion that was had in this thread.

 
  • Like
Reactions: 5632
To rebuild you are looking at a litttle over a $1100 in parts here are most ot them.
With out doing a tear down I can not know completely all the parts you will need.
But 300k on the motor most of the internal parts will need to be replaced.

With another $700-1000 in machine work depending on what the local cost are in your area
that would be Hot tanking the block, cleaning the passages after doing all the machine work, boring the cylinders, turning the crank,surfacing the block and head,doing a valve job (I included the valves (but your machine shop may only want to use valves and seats they supply).

I would have the Pistons Rods and Crank balanced.

If I was doing it for my Jeep I would clean up the ports with a dremel tool removing the rough surface ans smoothing out any casting makes. Then have the new seats installed you may need to go back and blend thearea just under the seats after they are instlled.
Port match your intake and exhuast manifolge and gaskets.

I would breaking the cam with the old valves then switch to the new spring after the cam is broken in.

No need to pull the head. Just remove all the spark plugs on each cylinder one at a time take about 24in of braided nylon 1/4 in rope with a fender washer on one end with a big knot to keep from feeding all the rope into the cylinder and on the comprision stroke rotate by hand untill the engine will not turn at tis point you can use you valve spring compressor wich is the lever type to push down on the retainer and remove the keepers.
I would use some aluminum foil wrapped around all the push rods to keep from dopping the keepers in to the engine. Most guy willl say to use air to hold the vales but by using the rope there is no way the valve can move and drop in to the cylinder. at this point install the new spring the reatainer and the keepers. Just repeat on all the vales a your done.
,



Engine : Cylinder Head Bolt
A
MAHLE / CLEVITE GS33414 Set; Steel
Info




Engine : Exhaust Valve
C
MELLING V1917
Info



+ Sold in packs of 2
Engine : Intake Valve
C
MELLING V1916
Info



+ Sold in packs of 2
Engine : Oil Pump
C
MELLING M167HVS Includes Oil Pickup Tube And Screen
Info

High Volume Pump


You'll need to drain and replace the Oil when installing a new oil pump.
Engine : Piston
C
SEALED POWER H802CP Hypereutectic; Alloy; Duroshield Coated Skirt; Ring Groove Widths: 1.5mm, 1.5mm, 4.0mm
Info

0.116 IN Deep Recess
Selected Size: Standard ($28.79/Each) {1}+ $28.790.030" Oversize ($18.05/Each) {6}+ $108.300.020" Oversize (Only 6 Remaining) ($19.98/Each) {6}+ $119.880.040" Oversize (Only 12 Remaining) ($19.98/Each) {6}+ $119.88
+ Sold in packs of x
Consider an Engine Repair Manual for in-depth repair and rebuilding information.
Engine : Push Rod
C
MELLING MPR437
Info



+ Sold in packs of 4
Engine : Rocker Arm
C
MELLING MRK5512 Kit
Info




Engine : Thrust Washer
B
DORMAN 618027 Inside Dia: 24.7mm; Outside Dia.: 45.1mm; Thickness: 4.7mm
Info


Selected (Only 7 Remaining) ($5.20/Each) {1}+ $5.20 ($1.32/Each) {5}+ $6.60
+ Sold in packs of x
Engine : Valve Spring
C
MELLING VS2225
Info


Selected ($3.68/Each) {1}+ $3.68 ($3.70/Each) {4}+ $14.80
+ Sold in packs of x
Engine : Engine Kit Gasket Set
A
MAHLE / CLEVITE 953568
Info




Consider an Engine Repair Manual for in-depth repair and rebuilding information.
Engine : Camshaft & Lifter Kit
C
MELLING CLMC1377
Info




[td] 2005 JEEP WRANGLER 4.0L L6[/td]
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$41.79​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$41.79
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$11.74​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$70.44
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$8.00​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$16.00
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$97.79​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$97.79
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$18.05​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$108.30
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$1.91​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$15.28
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$15.17​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$45.51
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$5.20​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$5.20
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$3.70​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$44.40
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$137.79​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$137.79
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
Part image
[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$352.79​
[/td][td width="1px"]
[/td][td width="1px"]
$352.79
[/td]​
[td]
Subtotal​
[/td][td width="1px"]
$935.29​
[/td]​
 
To rebuild you are looking at a litttle over a $1100 in parts here are most ot them.
With out doing a tear down I can not know completely all the parts you will need.
But 300k on the motor most of the internal parts will need to be replaced.

With another $700-1000 in machine work depending on what the local cost are in your area
that would be Hot tanking the block, cleaning the passages after doing all the machine work, boring the cylinders, turning the crank,surfacing the block and head,doing a valve job (I included the valves (but your machine shop may only want to use valves and seats they supply).

I would have the Pistons Rods and Crank balanced.

If I was doing it for my Jeep I would clean up the ports with a dremel tool removing the rough surface ans smoothing out any casting makes. Then have the new seats installed you may need to go back and blend thearea just under the seats after they are instlled.
Port match your intake and exhuast manifolge and gaskets.

I would breaking the cam with the old valves then switch to the new spring after the cam is broken in.

No need to pull the head. Just remove all the spark plugs on each cylinder one at a time take about 24in of braided nylon 1/4 in rope with a fender washer on one end with a big knot to keep from feeding all the rope into the cylinder and on the comprision stroke rotate by hand untill the engine will not turn at tis point you can use you valve spring compressor wich is the lever type to push down on the retainer and remove the keepers.
I would use some aluminum foil wrapped around all the push rods to keep from dopping the keepers in to the engine. Most guy willl say to use air to hold the vales but by using the rope there is no way the valve can move and drop in to the cylinder. at this point install the new spring the reatainer and the keepers. Just repeat on all the vales a your done.
,




Engine : Cylinder Head Bolt
A

MAHLE / CLEVITE GS33414 Set; Steel
Info



Engine : Exhaust Valve
C

MELLING V1917
Info



+ Sold in packs of 2
Engine : Intake Valve
C

MELLING V1916
Info



+ Sold in packs of 2
Engine : Oil Pump
C

MELLING M167HVS Includes Oil Pickup Tube And Screen
Info

High Volume Pump


You'll need to drain and replace the Oil when installing a new oil pump.
Engine : Piston
C

SEALED POWER H802CP Hypereutectic; Alloy; Duroshield Coated Skirt; Ring Groove Widths: 1.5mm, 1.5mm, 4.0mm
Info

0.116 IN Deep Recess
Selected Size: Standard ($28.79/Each) {1}+ $28.790.030" Oversize ($18.05/Each) {6}+ $108.300.020" Oversize (Only 6 Remaining) ($19.98/Each) {6}+ $119.880.040" Oversize (Only 12 Remaining) ($19.98/Each) {6}+ $119.88
+ Sold in packs of x
Consider an Engine Repair Manual for in-depth repair and rebuilding information.
Engine : Push Rod
C

MELLING MPR437
Info



+ Sold in packs of 4
Engine : Rocker Arm
C

MELLING MRK5512 Kit
Info



Engine : Thrust Washer
B

DORMAN 618027 Inside Dia: 24.7mm; Outside Dia.: 45.1mm; Thickness: 4.7mm
Info


Selected (Only 7 Remaining) ($5.20/Each) {1}+ $5.20 ($1.32/Each) {5}+ $6.60
+ Sold in packs of x
Engine : Valve Spring
C

MELLING VS2225
Info


Selected ($3.68/Each) {1}+ $3.68 ($3.70/Each) {4}+ $14.80
+ Sold in packs of x
Engine : Engine Kit Gasket Set
A

MAHLE / CLEVITE 953568
Info




Consider an Engine Repair Manual for in-depth repair and rebuilding information.
Engine : Camshaft & Lifter Kit
C

MELLING CLMC1377
Info



[td] 2005 JEEP WRANGLER 4.0L L6[/td]
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$41.79

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$41.79

[/td]​
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$11.74

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$70.44

[/td]​
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$8.00

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$16.00

[/td]​
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$97.79

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$97.79

[/td]​
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$18.05

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$108.30

[/td]​
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$1.91

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$15.28

[/td]​
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$15.17

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$45.51

[/td]​
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$5.20

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$5.20

[/td]​
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$3.70

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$44.40

[/td]​
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$137.79

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$137.79

[/td]​
[td width="1px"]


[/td]​
[td width="1px"]
$352.79

[/td][td width="1px"]




[/td][td width="1px"]
$352.79

[/td]​


[td]
Subtotal

[/td][td width="1px"]
$935.29

[/td]​

Doing all that, though good, is probably quite a bit longer down time than the OP wanted.

Speaking of, @KingCarGuyZ any updates?
 
Doing all that, though good, is probably quite a bit longer down time than the OP wanted.

Speaking of, @KingCarGuyZ any updates?

Parts came in earlier today - exhausted from work but probably start after classes tomorrow, got a ride to and from work Friday so might be able to squeeze in an extra day of down time.

It should be noted that going in, replacing only the pistons and the gaskets to get there, and getting back together ASAP is ill advised, and NOT what is best for the engine or from a labor perspective - that being said we are on a tight budget and an even tighter schedule, so some (most) things have to wait.