Dual batteries worth it or no? Set up looks nice man!!
I don't like to be stuck anywhere. I live in Arizona where it is extra hard on batteries. I cannot make up your mind for you, but I really like my set up. I wouldn't go as far as not recommended though. I don't see the problem of having two batteries, but there is definitely a couple caveats. There isn't much space for dual batteries. So odyssey makes a kit, but the cca is so low that your one battery probably has the same kick as their 2 battery setup that is really expensive. I didn't go for that package.
I went for the package that mounts to optima's sideways. I went with the Yellow tops. The caveat to that is after Interstate sold off optima they suck badly, but that said I have had a ton of problems with the Red tops and blue tops but I have had good luck with the Yellow tops of which that is what I have in there now. It has been a couple years and they are still going strong.
My two batteries are set up so I can isolate the aux battery, or I can charge or discharge both at the same time or even jump start the main battery off of the auxiliary battery. The set up was rather expensive, but I don't regret it. The two batteries are stacked on top of each other so they don't really take anymore room that you would be using anyway.
Here is a how to thread I wrote when I set mine up:
https://wranglertjforum.com/threads/how-to-install-dual-batteries-in-your-jeep-wrangler-tj.7166/
BTW I use my winch and I have never killed it completely with my winch, but I also tow a tent trailer with a fridge that I camp with overnight. I have installed power plugs in the bed of the Jeep for the cooler in case I don't take my trailer. My Yellow top ran my cooler all night with no issues then I charged it back up with a gen the next day. It is kind of nice not worrying about killing the aux battery, and still being able to start the jeep the next day.
It is a personal preference. When I set out to do it, I couldn't find any good info on it, so I know it isn't the most popular thing, and maybe it is not necessary, but I will tell you that my Chevy 3/4 with a camper also has dual batteries in it also. My main battery in my Chev is a pumped up Odysseey and my aux is a Yellow top Optima that I have had now for about 4 years. They are still going sttrong too. Before I had my TJ I had a YJ and I ran dual batteries in it also. The YJ has a ton more room for dual batteries though.
To me it is expensive, but worth it.