We went from an inexpensive Rampage top to a Bestop Supertop in Twill.
The Rampage top fit fine and worked as well as one would expect a $400 soft top to work.
It lasted about 6-7 years in the SoCal sun before several of the threads began to disintegrate from UV exposure (my best guess).
I repaired it a couple of times using a sewing awl, but when the entire seam along the door top gave up, so did I.
Rampage does not offer any replacement hardware, so a complete new top was in order for us.
Rather than buy another "inexpensive" soft top, we opted to sell our hard top and put that $$ towards a better soft top.
There have been issues w/ our Bestop, but nothing major.
I'm not a fan of how they market the Sunrider feature on the TJ; it is nowhere near as useful on the TJ top as it is on the JK (Freedom panel area only).
You cannot open the Sunrider on the TJ while seated, as it requires the outer trim/lip sections to be unlocked from the door surrounds, and the latches do not clear the sun visors (so they must be flipped down and/or to the side).
The rear logo pissed me off, but I hardly even notice it now.