I heard a 5.7L Hemi a couple months back and it surprisingly didn't move the needle for me like I thought it would. And, I drove out of my way to check out that rig all because I had never seen a Hemi in a TJ.
A 5.7L Hemi is a lot of effort for only a bit more power than a turbo'd 4.0L gives you (without as much effort).
Obviously, things get very impressive once you are in the 6.0L-6.4L builds, which bring on fitment issues and dealing with heat management (just what you need). Those builds are awesome, but it's not a lighthearted route to pursue since it takes time and effort or a load of cash.