Actually
@Chris is the king. He covered the tub on his old TJ with sound deadener and thick rubber mat. In a very professional way. He has pics somewhere. It was the nicest job I've ever seen. I used his advice and researched this alot. I just took more pics and wrote about it during the installation.
But I think 157mil or 200mil is way overkill. Your not blocking noise so much as your stopping noise from vibration in the tub steel. Single panels in major areas can do that. And if you want to block noise - not so much "deaden" the vibrations - I would use that thick rubber mat. I forget the technical name. But Noico sold it. It's like .5" thick foam rubber of sorts. But I assume it's heavy too.
200mil weight alone is going to add up fast. You don't realize how heavy this stuff is until you pick up a box. A 6 inch thick box of this is heavy as hell. Like hard to pick up. You add this a couple steel bumpers and rock sliders. And your going to slow down and need to start second guessing a lift or other additional weight. This why everyone puts bigger motors in. And why alot of guys run stock.
They spent millions engineering the TJ. For a perfect match of weight and power. Not to much and not to little. But the aftermarket options are many. Second battery, bumpers, sliders, onboard air, extra gas, gear. It adds up quick. And the 4.0 tractor engine, while being massively reliable and rugged, is not a major powerhouse. But it was engineered that way.
My advice? No harm in starting with less. See what you get. Then add more if you need too.
I was going doing the same thing. Trying to kill as much noise as possible. I ended up with Caddilac thick plush carpet. And a thick layer of sound deadening and heat shield. It was a bit overkill for a Jeep to be honest. And with a soft top your only going to get so far.
Just consider your entire build first. Figure out a max weight that the TJ can handle above stock. Then add up everything you want to do first. Then decide if that extra 100lbs of sound deadening is worth swapping for your extra battery or sliders or whatever. Or at least start with single panels of 60mil.
It's like backpacking. You don't buy a pack first. Because you'll fill it with bs and it will quickly become to heavy. And you'll be slow and weak. Just like your Jeep.
Figure out what you "need" to take first. Then buy a backpack just large enough to fit it all. Or a Jeep that isn't going to be strapped with to much weight.
You add all this sh*t. And then at some point you realize your Jeep is to heavy. And power is suffering. And just like a backpack you have to much sh*t. And already missing items that are essential to your build.
Make a spreadsheet of weights. Ask
@Chris or some of the OG members what that weight limit is. Or a range. And plan accordingly. Don't buy shit first. And start adding it. You can't return sound deadener once it's applied. And honestly you can't remove it. It's a major bitch. Like I wouldn't even try.
Read and research hotrods. Those guys use sound deadener way more. And their goals are way more silent. They know what works. Same with audio guys.