I had the same Rugged Ridge Spartacus. The thing was rock solid. Tailgate closed with a finger. Only short comings were there were that the pivot points weren't servicable and the deal killer for me that I couldn't install the Bestop Cargo Basket brackets. I use the basket a few times a month and being able to remove it is key.
I lucked out and found a
Bestop HighRock 4x4 HD Tire Carrier from a member here. Bestop stopped selling it years ago. Also rock solid. Serviceable pivot points. Zero rattles. Tub & tailgate mounted swing out. If one can be found, I highly recommend it.
View attachment 580154